Black Friday60% off a year · £1 a month for 3 monthsClaim the deal
TF Gaming
Guides

Crit damage or attack? The balance rule for better damage

5 November 2026 · Clive Walkden

You have a new piece of gear with two options for the next substat, or a pair of gloves that could be C.DMG or ATK%. Which one makes your champion hit harder?

It depends on your champion's numbers, and there is a quick way to tell. Compare how much bigger your total attack is than your base attack with your crit damage. Whichever is lagging behind is the stat that adds the most damage.

The short answer

For a champion whose damage scales from ATK:

Total ATK ÷ Base ATK compared with 1 + C.DMG

  • If Total ÷ Base is lower, add ATK (ATK% substats, ATK% main stats).
  • If Total ÷ Base is higher, add C.DMG.
  • If they are close, either is fine: spend the substat on whatever else the champion needs (speed, accuracy).
The balance rule
The balance rule: compare Total ÷ Base with 1 + C.DMG, and add whichever is behind

Prefer not to do the sum? The Crit Damage Calculator does it: pick your champion and it fills in which stat it scales from and its base at 6★ level 60, then type in your total and C.DMG.

The Crit Damage Calculator
The first example below in the calculator: 2.50 against 2.20, so crit damage is the better stat

Swap ATK for DEF or HP if that is what your champion's skills scale from. C.DMG is written as a decimal in the sum, so 150% C.DMG becomes 1 + 1.5 = 2.5.

Where to find the numbers

Open the champion in the game and look at their stats. Each stat is shown as the base value (the champion's own stat at their rank and level) plus a green bonus from gear, masteries, the Great Hall and so on. Your total is the two added together.

  • Base ATK: the first number.
  • Total ATK: base plus the green bonus.
  • C.DMG: shown as a percentage. Most champions start at 50%.

Not sure which stat a champion scales from? Read the damage skills: the description of an attack says what it is based on, and the champion's role is a good hint. Defenders usually scale from DEF, support champions often from HP, attackers from ATK.

Two examples

An ATK champion. Base ATK 1,200, total ATK 3,000, C.DMG 120%.

  • Total ÷ Base = 3,000 ÷ 1,200 = 2.5
  • 1 + C.DMG = 1 + 1.2 = 2.2

The ATK side is bigger, so C.DMG is the better stat right now. Checking it the long way:

Option New value Crit damage goes up by
+10% ATK (10% of the 1,200 base) 3,120 ATK 3,120 ÷ 3,000 = 4.0%
+10% C.DMG 130% C.DMG 2.3 ÷ 2.2 = 4.5%

A DEF champion. Base DEF 1,400, total DEF 2,800, C.DMG 150%.

  • Total ÷ Base = 2,800 ÷ 1,400 = 2.0
  • 1 + C.DMG = 1 + 1.5 = 2.5

This time the C.DMG side is bigger, so DEF is the better stat: +10% DEF adds 5% to every crit, +10% C.DMG adds 4%.

Why it works

A critical hit does roughly skill multiplier × your scaling stat × (1 + C.DMG). Two things grow that number:

  • A percentage of ATK, DEF or HP from gear is a percentage of your base stat, not your total. So each 1% adds less and less as your total grows.
  • C.DMG adds straight onto the (1 + C.DMG) part, so each 1% adds less and less as your crit damage grows.

Each stat's next point is worth most when the other one has run ahead. They are worth the same when Total ÷ Base equals 1 + C.DMG: that is the balance point. Below it, the stat is behind; above it, crit damage is.

The rule treats 1% of ATK and 1% of C.DMG as equally easy to get. In practice substat rolls and main stats differ a little, so think of it as a compass, not a calculator: if you are within about 10% of balanced, other stats matter more.

The quick rule of thumb

You may have heard a simpler version from the community:

  • ATK or DEF champions: about 100% C.DMG for every 2,000 total ATK or DEF
  • HP champions: about 100% C.DMG for every 30,000 total HP

These are handy for a glance at a team in the middle of the game, but they assume a typical base stat. The ratio above uses your champion's own base, so it stays right as champions and gear change. Credit to Ash's guide, Raid Shadow Legends: the damage balance rule, for both.

Before you balance: three checks

  1. Crit rate first. Crit damage only counts when you crit. Damage dealers want C.RATE at or near 100% before any of this matters.
  2. Mixed skills. A few skills scale from two stats (ATK and HP, say). Balance against the stat with the bigger number in the skill, or leave them alone.
  3. Skills based on the enemy. Some hits are a share of the target's MAX HP. Your own ATK does nothing for those, so C.DMG is the only stat on this list that helps them.

Buffs move the balance too. Increase ATK and Increase DEF work from your base stat, so with a buffer in the team your total climbs and C.DMG becomes the better stat sooner.

Let Raid Aegis do the legwork

Working this out for one champion takes a minute with the Crit Damage Calculator. Finding the gear to fix it is the slow part: the right piece is usually sitting somewhere in a vault of hundreds.

Raid Aegis reads your account from the game. Each champion's page shows its stats exactly as the game's Total Stats screen does, base and total, so the two numbers this rule needs are already there. It grades every artifact from Bin to Godlike for the stage of the game you are at and shows which champions each good piece suits. It is free to start.

A champion's stats in Raid Aegis
Base, bonus and total for every stat, and (Premium) the balance check worked out for you

In short

  • Divide total by base for your champion's scaling stat. Compare it with 1 + C.DMG.
  • Lower: add ATK, DEF or HP. Higher: add C.DMG.
  • Sort crit rate first, and do not sweat small differences.
Track your own account with Raid Aegis

Champions, gear, events and fusions, read straight from your game.

Start free

More news